The Importance of Projections

A few days ago I found a wonderful story about polar ice caps melting that led me to some wonderful data. I thought I could potentially make a viz that showed the changing extent of the sea ice at the poles – some line charts for the temporal view and a map with the shape files. I figured some animation would be even sexier.

I pulled the shape files down from the web and used Alteryx to union them together into a single file (+1 vote for shape file union). I loaded it into Tableau and drew my map but I got this:

WTF!?! Something is very broken. I decided to take a closer look at a single shape file:

Yep – definitely borked somewhere. My initial thought was that maybe there was a problem with the polygon data – that perhaps the polygons weren’t being closed properly. Because look here…

But surely not. I mean, these people are professionals. I’m sure their data is used all the time and an error like this would certainly be flagged. I downloaded and installed QGIS, pointed it at the file (and the Tableau tile service) and voila! One sea ice polygon:

BTW – check out how QGIS takes our Tile Service and projects it nicely. Very cool!

Anyhow – it turns out the problem is with the projection in the data. The shape file has the data in EPSG:3412 (NSIDC Sea Ice Polar Stereographic South). However, Tableau only understands WGS 84 (Web Mercator) and so it is doing on-the-fly transformations. Here’s what happens when I transform the data into a Mercator projection in QGIS:

BOOM! Also borked. I’m no GIS expert (looks around for Sarah Battersby) but it looks like Mercator can’t handle polygons that cross the +/- 180 degree meridian. So until Tableau can support more projections, I’m going to have to park this project. Or like Sarah suggested, map it to completely different coordinates somewhere else on the globe.

Learnin’ every day, folks.

About Alan Eldridge

Hi. I'm Alan. By day I manage the APAC sales engineering team for Snowflake Computing. By night, I'm a caped crusader. Or sleeping. Most often it's sleeping.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to The Importance of Projections

  1. John Chew says:

    It began with Alteryx so wouldn’t it be poetic to solve it with Alteryx without having to wait for more projections to become available in Tableau?

  2. Pingback: I am not worthy… | The Last Data Bender

  3. Pingback: How to visualize polar projection data in Tableau | The Last Data Bender

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s